R08 · v1.0 signed 2026-08-31
Living Soil & Indoor No-Till: What the Evidence Actually Supports
Can living-soil and no-till methods work indoors for cannabis, and what does the evidence say about yield, biology, inputs and multi-cycle reuse?
Who did what
| Role | System | Model, as recorded |
|---|---|---|
| Researcher | ChatGPT | ChatGPT Deep Research |
| Researcher | Gemini | Gemini Deep Research |
| Editor and verifier | Claude | Claude Fable 5 |
| Cross-auditor | ChatGPT | not recorded |
Brief and prompts
- ClaudeBrief2.5k words
- ClaudeKickoff prompts909 words
Independent research (raw, as received)
- ChatGPTChatGPT research pass · 2026-08-314.9k words
- GeminiGemini research pass · 2026-08-315.5k words
Verification, critique and corrections
- ClaudeCorrection round (Gemini)1.1k words
- ClaudeVerification & critique2.8k words
- ClaudeVerification A1.5k words
- ClaudeVerification B1.3k words
- ClaudeVerification C1.5k words
- ClaudeVerify corrections2.3k words
Ledger and synthesis
- ClaudeClaim ledger3.3k words
- ClaudeClaim ledger, plain language1.4k words
- ClaudeSynthesis2.1k words
- ClaudeSynthesis, plain language1.2k words
Cross-model audit
- ClaudeClaude audit · 2026-09-02762 words
The first cross-model audit ran on this round. It found an error the editor had introduced during verification, which led to the standing audit rules.